Annie’s Choice 12″ Quilt Block Tutorial

Learn how to make an Annie’s Choice quilt block with our free twelve-inch quilt block tutorial and pattern.

green and white quilt block on white cutting mat

If you love classic quilt designs with timeless charm, the Annie’s Choice quilt block is one you’ll definitely want to add to your collection. This traditional block features a beautiful mix of half-square triangles that come together to create a dynamic variation on a simple Sawtooth Star block design.

It’s simple enough for confident beginners, yet interesting enough to keep experienced quilters engaged.

A Little History of the Block

The Annie’s Choice quilt block is a traditional quilt pattern that dates back to the early 1900s, when it was published in several quilt newspapers and pattern catalogs. Over the years, variations of Annie’s Choice have appeared under different names, but the essence of the block remains the same.

Note: This block can also be made using a combination of Flying Geese and Half Square Triangle blocks; however, today we are making it using the eight-at-a-time half-square triangle method, which I feel is a quicker method.

green and white quilt block on white cutting mat

Annie’s Choice 12″ Quilt Block Pattern

Melissa Mortenson
How to make an Annie's Choice quilt block using the eight at a time half square triangles method.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 30 minutes
Active Time 1 hour
Total Time 1 hour 30 minutes

supplies

  • 1 Fat Quarter Fabric A
  • 1 Fat Quarter Fabric B

Instructions
 

  • Block is 12 1/2" x 12 1/2" BEFORE Finishing

Cut:

  • From Fabric A:
    2 Squares 8" x 8"
  • From Fabric B:
    2 Squares 8" x 8"

Step One: Mark the Fabric

  • Draw an X diagonally on the wrong side of the lighter square of fabric.
    herringbone quilt illustration

Step Two: Pin

  • Pin one marked fabric square with one square from a 2nd fabric, right sides facing.

Step Three: Sew

  • Ensure you know the 1/4″ seam mark on your sewing machine foot. For these steps, stitching exactly 1/4″ on each side of the line is essential.
  • Stitch 1/4″ on each side of the line you drew in both directions.
    herringbone quilt illustration

Step Four: Cut

  • You are now ready to cut your square into eight smaller pieces. Using your rotary cutter and quilt ruler, make four cuts.
    herringbone quilt illustration
  • First, cut a line horizontally across your block precisely in the center. Next, make a vertical cut also in the center.
  • The last cuts are made diagonally along the line you drew in step one.
    herringbone quilt illustration

Step Five: Press & Trim

  • You should now have eight pieces of fabric. Open up the HSTs and press the seam towards the darker fabric.
  • Trim up each sewn HST to 3 1/2" x 3 1/2"
    herringbone quilt illustration
  • Repeat all steps one more time to have sixteen sewn units.

Step Six: Assemble Block

  • There are a few ways to assemble this block from the sewn HSTs. I think the simplest way is to sew the rows of the block together then sew the rows to each other.
  • Using the chart as a guide, sew Row 1, Row 2, Row 3 & Row 4
  • Sew the rows together. Trim and square up the block to 12 1/2" x 12 1/2"
PRINT
Love this tutorial? Get the behind the scenes on Instagram

Additional Free 12″ Quilt Block Patterns

  1. Churn Dash Quilt Block
  2. Log Cabin Quilt Block
  3. Friendship Star Quilt Block
  4. Economy Block
  5. Shoo-Fly Quilt Block
  6. Bear Paw Quilt Block
  7. Maple Leaf Quilt Block
  8. Maple Star Quilt Block
  9. Nine Patch Quilt Block
  10. Turnstile Quilt Block
  11. Sawtooth Star Quilt Block
  12. Bow Tie Quilt Block
  13. Ohio Star Quilt Block
  14. Pinwheel Star Quilt Block
  15. Basket Quilt Block

Similar Posts